Neil Young Fights For High Resolution Digital

So, here’s the deal… Young is a bit misinformed. While I agree totally with his point (OCCUPY AUDIO!), his idea of what the digital full-resolution equivalent requires is wrong. 24 bit/88.2kHz audio may as well be 100% with 24/44.1kHz being marginally lower (99% maybe). All anything above 44.1kHz gets you is double the file size for a little low pass filter noise shifting out of the audible range on lower end systems that don’t themselves upsample before filtering. You can have high resolution digital today with a FLAC or ALAC 24bit files. And it will play on EXISTING iPhones/iPods/etc (at least the 44.1kHz ALAC will). What needs to happen is simply that the high res digital formats need to be made available to purchase. No new players are needed (though bigger harddrives would be nice). The file size of ALAC is only about 8 times that of a iTunes download. And, BTW, Bandcamp sites can already offer this.

But that aside… hell yes. And you don’t need to be an audio geek with a expensive system to get a full picture of high res audio. An iPhone with a decent set of open-back headphones and inexpensive outboard amp will do wonders. If you care about music, you should demand it. And while your at it, demand that the 24bit versions retain the full dynamic range — in other words aren’t limited and compressed to death from an audio (not data) standpoint.

This is my favorite audio analogy:
High-res 24bit file/vinyl == Hardcover book.
Heavily limited “Loud” CD/16bit lossless file == Paperback.
MP3/AAC/any other lossy format == Cliffs notes.

This entry was posted in Articles, Videocasts. Bookmark the permalink. Post a comment or leave a trackback: Trackback URL.

3 Trackbacks

  1. By audio mastering chain on October 4, 2012 at 12:37 pm

    audio mastering chain…

    Neil Young Fights For High Resolution Digital | JimmyEther.com…

  2. By Arjun Kanuri on May 9, 2013 at 8:32 am

    Arjun Kanuri…

    Neil Young Fights For High Resolution Digital | JimmyEther.com…

  3. By amazon coupon 2013 on January 28, 2014 at 5:11 pm

    amazon coupon 2013…

    Neil Young Fights For High Resolution Digital | JimmyEther.com…

Post a Comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.

  • Scan This QR Code



    To send contact and mastering pricing info to your phone, scan the image above with your phone's QR reader. Click to enlarge.

  • Mastering Specials

    Make A Complete Album in 16 Hours
    There's two things that I feel strongly about:
    • A recording should be a document of sound in place and time which should immerse the listener in that moment.
    • Bands should not invest more in a recording than they should reasonably be able to make back in less than one year.
    And that's why I've crafted this package. It gives bands a meticulously tracked, mixed and mastered release that honestly documents 16 hours of hard work. And at the current sale price, a band can break even with 400 digital album sales at $5 each.

    Currently on sale!


    $3,000.00
    $2,000.00
  • Not ready to pull the trigger on the mastering yet? Wanna chat first? Just click on the handy-dandy Google Voice widget above, enter your phone number and we'll be connected. It's magic.

    Or non-magically email mastering [at] jimmyether [dot] com (though email is still kinda magical).

  • Topics

  • Archives

  • Meta

  • Product Categories

  • “Like” This Site?

    If you like what I'm doing here, want to be kept informed via Facebook and don't mind your friends knowing you "like" me, then click the little "Like" button below. Don't worry. I'll know you just "like" me... not "LIKE-like" me.

  • Mailing List

    Subscribe for occasional newsletters, mastering specials & giveaways (ie. FREE MASTERING).






    * = required field

    powered by MailChimp!
  • Follow Me!

    Follow me on Twitter. This I command. Hey, look... this is the crap I've been saying!